top of page
Writer's pictureRusty Johnson

"Owls at Odds: The Spotted vs. Barred Dilemma"



Barred Owl
A Barred Owl

As early as next spring, a controversial and challenging decision will take place in the forests of the Pacific Northwest: the culling of barred owls. This plan, finalized by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, aims to kill as many as 450,000 barred owls over the next 30 years across Washington, Oregon, and California. The purpose? To save the endangered spotted owl from extinction.


Why Target the Barred Owl?


Rusty with his Barred Owl
Rusty with his Barred Owl

The barred owl, originally a native of the East Coast, has steadily migrated westward over the past century. This species has become a significant threat to the spotted owl, a native species that has been listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act since 1990. As Kessina Lee, the state supervisor for the Oregon office of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, explains, this cull is not about wiping out the barred owl but rather ensuring that both the barred and spotted owls can coexist in the future. "This is about carving out that space for spotted owls to have the space to persist," Lee said.


The reality is that the spotted owl is being outcompeted and even preyed upon by the more aggressive barred owl. The latter has disrupted the ecosystem by significantly reducing populations of other species like salamanders, flying squirrels, wood rats, and screech owls. Protecting the spotted owl could help restore balance to these ecosystems, making the spotted owl an "umbrella species"—one whose conservation helps protect many other species.


The Difficult Decision


It’s crucial to understand that this decision to cull barred owls was not made lightly. As biologists and wildlife professionals, those at the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service are deeply committed to ethical conservation. Lee emphasizes their responsibility to prevent the extinction of the spotted owl, a species now in a steep decline. The cull would target less than half of one percent of the barred owl population in North America, a calculated effort to make a significant difference without devastating the species.


This will not be a public, open hunt. Instead, specially trained shooters will work with landowners, using nonlead shotguns at close range, typically at dusk or night, when barred owls are most active. The goal is to minimize suffering and focus efforts in areas where spotted owl populations are most at risk.


Voices of Opposition


Despite the careful planning, the cull has sparked sharp criticism. Wayne Pacelle, president of Animal Wellness Action and the Center for a Humane Economy, argues that this would be the largest raptor cull ever undertaken by any government worldwide, with no similar precedent. He notes that barred owls are merely expanding their range in response to human-driven environmental changes—a situation likely to occur more frequently as climate change continues to alter habitats.


Pacelle and others argue that barred owls, being native to North America for millions of years, will never be completely eradicated and will likely continue to move into areas left vacant by the cull. He calls the plan impractical, questioning who would be willing to participate in such a task over such a vast area, given the logistical and ethical challenges involved.


A Broader Conservation Lesson


The predicament we face with the spotted and barred owls is a sobering reminder of the broader issues in conservation. Bob Sallinger, executive director of Bird Conservation Oregon, points out the tragic irony of our actions: "It’s a bit of a tragedy, these things we do as human beings, the unintended consequences, and the hubris." The loss of old-growth forests due to logging has already pushed the spotted owl to the brink, and now we are forced to take drastic measures to save what remains.


The Northwest Forest Plan, adopted in 1994, was supposed to protect the spotted owl by halting logging on 24 million acres of old-growth forest. Despite this effort, spotted owl numbers have continued to decline, leading us to this moment where a choice must be made—one that weighs the life of one species against the survival of another.


Conclusion: The Need for Proactive Conservation


This situation underscores the importance of proactive habitat conservation to prevent such dilemmas from arising. Once a species becomes imperiled, it is exceedingly difficult to bring it back from the brink. As Sallinger aptly puts it, "Once a species is imperiled, it is very hard to get it back." The story of the barred and spotted owls is a call to action for more thoughtful and sustainable environmental stewardship, to ensure that we are not forced to make such difficult decisions in the future.


Join Rusty's Patreon Today!

Join Rusty's Patreon Today!


Recent Posts

See All

Comentarios


bottom of page